Don McLean’s “American Pie 55th Anniversary Tour” stop at Troy Savings Bank Music Hall Saturday, Nov. 14 was bittersweet.

Part of the “bitter” could have been the band’s narrow arrival at the historic theater due to complications from the nationwide ground stop for air travel. (Sort of Friday the 13th horror lingering to Saturday the 14th.)
The four-man performing team reportedly arrived without luggage, including many, if not all of their instruments, only an hour and nine minutes before their scheduled performance. Sound checks were still being done as ticketholders queued outside the theater waiting for the doors to open a little after 7p.m. for the 8 p.m. show. (See post note at end of review.)

“We had some plane issues,” McLean said, strapping on an acoustic guitar after sitting center-stage. “But we don’t believe in canceling.
“You would never see me playing a Gibson guitar,” he added, referring to the improvised choice of instrument he was about to play for the entire show. “But otherwise it would have been ukulele or comb and paper.”

His bandmates had to take a train in addition to a plane to get to the show, McLean told the audience. Setlist.fm shows the group’s last performance prior to Troy, NY was Nov. 11 in Phoenix, AZ.
The “sweet” in Saturday’s bittersweet performance included McLean’s still-strong, clear voice, which in my opinion is lower and has taken on some of the characteristics of Johnny Cash (but less gravelly) with a hint of Neil Young perhaps, since its early days in the 1970s.

McLean also sweetly complimented the audience and the music hall venue several times, and, as has been his mission since his landmark hit, “American Pie,” in 1971, he paid tribute to Buddy Holly and old-style rock n’ roll, leading off with Ricky Nelson’s “Believe What You Say.”
The lively rockabilly sound continued with a honkytonkish, twangy rendition of “Fool’s Paradise,” but not before McLean dealt one of a few mild jabs at Rolling Stone Magazine, with whom he has had a tense relationship for decades.

McLean called seeing the growth and longevity of “American Pie’s” popularity “an honor” despite Rolling Stone’s “want[ing] me gone. I’m still here.”
McClean, originally from New Rochelle, NY, credited Lena Spencer of Café Lena in Saratoga Springs with helping him start his musical career in 1968.
“I was just getting out of college…She started this club, and because of her, I got a job with the State of New York playing at every river town.
…If you learned a couple chords, you could get a job…you could earn $100 a weekend even playing badly…There were all these little coffee houses, everybody trying hard to be a musician, but an ear musician, not trained. [You]couldn’t read music…You could still make money.
Don McLean
This kind of harsh honesty, unfiltered, is part of the “bittersweet” that surfaced several times Saturday in Troy: from references to the blacklisting of The Weavers, one of McLean’s musical influences in the 1950s, to lyrics about exploitation in “Bronco Bill’s Lament” (1972) (“Oh God, how I worked away my youth…”) and the social commentary of “Headroom” (1990) and “Magdalene Lane” (1970).

There has always been a cynical edge to McLean’s songwriting, religious references and spiritual struggle, but an unpretentiousness. When I met him briefly backstage after a show at Chautauqua Institution in 1982, he was wearing a dark green hoodie and jeans and had been mistaken as one of the roadies. But there was a sweetness in his delivery then, and something so poetic, honest and personal that it could silence audiences and nearly bring them to tears. “Vincent” is a perfect example with the tender guitar phrasing and McLean’s voice slowing and almost quietly speaking: “They could not love you but still your love was true…but I could have told you, Vincent, this life was never meant for one as beautiful as you.”

Yet, after spending an hour and a half in McLean’s audience Saturday, despite numbers such as the soft “And I Love You So,” and the lilting “Lovers Love the Spring,” some of that tenderness seemed missing: the gentle pacing, the almost dreamlike acoustic guitar sound, the vulnerability, the wistfulness, yet the hope, replaced sometimes with a deeper voice, a louder delivery and a less hopeful, more cynical outlook.

At one point, a few numbers into his set, McLean commented, “A lot of big names say they can’t do their tour because of their mental health. If I had done that, I wouldn’t perform…You have to suck it up. You can’t do that (cancel) to people.”
At another point later in the show, he told the audience he had learned two things over the years: one, there is heightened competitiveness and a lack of sportsmanship, and, two, that we shouldn’t look to our government to keep us safe.

Finally, after introducing his band, Nashville-based Matt McKenzie on bass, John McTigue III on drums and Garrett Stoner on electric guitar, whom McLean quipped was “also excellent at making [last-minute] travel plans,” McLean announced that “American Boys,” his twenty-second studio album released in 2024, would be his last.

I’m done with songwriting pretty much…I’ve said everything I can say… So I’m through. I’m not like some musicians who have to produce a hundredth album so they can stay relevant. I’m not relevant. I’ve never been relevant, and I want to stay irrelevant…There are about 400 tracks of me out there. That ought to last you a couple weeks at least.

After the title cut to American Boys and “Travelin’ Man,” the well-known Ricky Nelson tune, McLean and his back-up musicians launched into McLean’s iconic, 8-minute show topper and the namesake of the current tour, “American Pie.”

It may not have been the “American Pie” I sang along to at age 11; it may not have had the same sweet-voiced delivery with its little tempo shifts and surprising vocal swings (“eight miles high and falling faa-a-ast,”); but still it had the classic, cryptic lyrics and the refrain the audience could and did belt out, and hopefully it still afforded some pride and joy for its creator.

So, with that said, Mr. McLean, I respectfully and strongly disagree with your comments about relevance. With more than 50 million records sold and still selling, the American Troubadour’s music is extremely relevant. If only by virtue of being so personal, so intimately communicated, what started out as personal has become universal. What may have been judged as “irrelevant” remains highly relevant because it’s a slice of human experience.
Old poets don’t stop communicating, Don. They speak to the heart forever, no matter how cryptically.

POST NOTE: Garrett Stoner, who played guitar Saturday night in Troy for Don McLean’s performance, lingered on stage after the show to tell fans a bit about band members’ delays due to the telecommunications glitches which left planes grounded and luggage enmired across the country Friday into Saturday. I wasn’t in position to hear everything, but I understood Stoner to say the three back-up musicians were stranded temporarily in Chicago, made their way eventually to Laguardia in New York, took the train from New York to Albany and rode an Uber to the Troy Music Hall with basically just the clothes on their backs. “It is what it is,” Stoner shrugged, noting they made friends with fellow travelers stranded in Chicago.
Of note perhaps, Stoner’s name, as well as Mackenzie’s and McTigue’s are not the names of the musicians listed as being on McLean’s 55th Anniversary American Pie Tour.
Stoner said the band would drive to their next engagement in New Jersey.
Other bands affected by the nationwide flight stoppage apparently also took the inconvenience in stride and made the best of their situation. News reports and Internet videos show Hoobastank, the Used and Simple Plan entertaining travelers with an impromptu concert on a Southwest flight bound for Orlando Friday afternoon. The flight had already embarked when the FAA paused takeoffs, reports said.

Setlist: Believe What You Say (Ricky Nelson cover), Fool’s Paradise, Botanical Gardens, Lucky Guy, And I Love You So, Magdalene Lane, Hide Nor Hair (Percy Mayfield cover), I’m Gonna Sit Right Down and Write Myself a Letter (Fred Ahlert/Joe Young cover), Lovers Love the Spring, Bronco Bill’s Lament, Homeless Brother, Vincent, Head Room, American Boys, Travelin’ Man (Ricky Nelson Cover), American Pie








Bluesky Discussion
View on BlueskyNo replies yet. Be the first to comment on Bluesky!
Comments are closed.